[Salon] MbS slips the pariah trap



MbS slips the pariah trap

Summary: as President Biden seeks to turn Putin into a global pariah, he has let slip another target, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, who is increasingly gaining international approval and acceptance despite his ruthless suppression of Saudis at home and attacks on critics abroad.

We thank Sami Hamdi for today’s newsletter.  Sami is editor in chief of The International Interest and a frequent contributor to the Arab Digest Podcast.  You can find his most recent podcast ‘The Middle East weighs up the Taliban triumph’ here.

Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman began 2021 convinced that the advent of the Biden administration heralded a disaster. The incoming president had promised to render Bin Salman a ‘pariah’, release the CIA report into the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, end US support for Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen, and ‘recalibrate the relationship’ between Washington and Riyadh.

Such was the sense of impending disaster that the prince unilaterally lifted the blockade on Qatar and began an expedited reconciliation process with Doha, simultaneously dragging along a bewildered UAE, Egypt and Bahrain. Saudi officials were fulsome in their praise of Biden in a bid to  stave off or at least soften the impending blow.

Undeterred, President Biden proceeded to announce an end to US support for the Saudi military operations in Yemen. The CIA report that implicated the Saudi crown prince directly in the Khashoggi killing was released (although Biden stopped short of imposing sanctions.) And the president proceeded to announce that he would only communicate with the head of state, thereby asserting that he would not recognise Mohmmed bin Salman’s authority as the de facto ruler of the kingdom.

Low oil prices were putting a strain on the Saudi economy and finances, while international companies were demonstrating a reluctance to fully engage with the numerous projects being marketed by Riyadh under the NEOM and Vision 2030 banners.

Yet, a year and a half later, the situation is markedly different. Today, it is Biden chasing MbS for a phone conversation, and it is the Saudi crown prince who is ignoring the US president. The shift in the political dynamics that govern the Saudi-US relationship over the past year and a half has been nothing short of seismic as the Biden administration struggles to navigate a region in which nearly every US ally is disgruntled with Washington and seeking alternative leverage to deploy against the White House.


Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman greets Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan upon his arrival in Jeddah, 28 April 2022

MbS’s international isolation was broken last December when French President Emmanuel Macron became the first Western head of state to visit Riyadh and publicly meet with the Saudi crown prince. Although the visit was driven by a desire on the part of Macron to discuss the crisis in Lebanon, it was a public demonstration of MbS’s relevance in spite of Biden’s attitude.

The stand-off between Biden and MbS continued until the outbreak of the war in Ukraine. With oil prices spiking dramatically Washington became very keen to speak with Riyadh. There was talk of attempts at telephone calls between the president and MbS with the latter, in an ironic twist, declining to take the president’s call.

Instead, the crown prince received UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson who became the second Western leader to visit him in Riyadh. Although Johnson had set out to convince MbS to raise oil production, the visit itself laid bare the increasing difficulty for the international community to ignore Saudi Arabia and isolate its leadership. And last week Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdoğan became the third world leader to make the journey to Riyadh as the prince’s rehabilitation continues to build pace.

However, it is not only in relationships with heads of state that MbS is experiencing a sudden change of fortune. Since reconciling with Qatar, influential Qatari media outlets have significantly toned down their criticism of his policies while Doha appears to be altering the narrative regarding its association with the Muslim Brotherhood. Former Qatari Prime Minister Hamad Bin Jassim told Kuwait’s Al-Qabas in an interview that: “the Muslim Brotherhood might be trusted to run a shop, but not a state”. Ahead of his visit to the kingdom, Turkey’s Erdoğan was busy chasing reconciliation and offering concessions including the imposition of restrictions on the activity of opposition figures in Istanbul and, as well, he ordered the State Prosecutor to halt the proceedings in the Khashoggi case and allow its transfer to the Saudi authorities.

Even in Yemen, MbS has seen an improvement in his fortunes. US officials have been stunned at the lack of reciprocity from the Houthis to American overtures for talks, despite Biden’s lifting of the terrorist designation. US Secretary of State Anthony Blinken even reportedly apologised to UAE’s crown prince Mohammed bin Zayed on behalf of Biden for not taking a firmer stance against the Houthis following their attack on Abu Dhabi.

More importantly, MbS and the UAE’s MbZ have successfully managed to engineer a reconfiguring of the power dynamics in Yemen’s internationally-recognised government by imposing a new ‘Presidential Leadership Council’ that resoundingly chains the Islah (Yemen’s Muslim Brotherhood), and elevates Riyadh and Abu Dhabi’s allies. Vice President Ali Mohsen Al-Ahmar of the Islah has been removed, while Saudi and UAE allies Aidrous Al-Zubeidi of the separatist Southern Transitional Council, Tareq Salah (the nephew of former Yemen strongman Ali Abdullah Saleh) and Abu Zara'a al-Muharrami of the ‘Giants Brigade’ that broke the Houthi offensive in Ma’rib, have all been elevated. The leadership council also sets the stage for more pragmatic negotiations on Yemen geared towards recognising individual fiefdoms and autonomous regions as opposed to restoring a unified authority in Sanaa. Such an outcome is more in line with Saudi Arabia’s historical position on Yemen which has always been against unification.

Domestically, the crown prince has been able to forcefully accelerate his de-Islamisation drive. The Saudi General Entertainment Authority has sought to break taboos by inviting raunchy entertainers such as Nicki Minaj to perform in the kingdom. A ban on the use of loudspeakers for Quranic recitations in mosques is in place, with an exemption for them to be used for the call to prayer provided they are only used at a third of their volume. In Jeddah, also known as the ‘gate of Mecca’, the first Saudi bikini beach has been introduced.

The crown prince has also altered the history of Saudi Arabia in a bid to disassociate the Saudi identity from the Islamic fervour that drove its establishment. The date of the founding of the kingdom has been changed from 1744 to 1727 in a bid to erase the role of Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab and present a revised history in which the founding  is held to be a uniquely nationalist endeavour by Al Saud, one that denies that the Islamic fervour of Abd al-Wahhab was an essential pillar of the state.

The policy of imprisoning swathes of opponents also appears to have had the desired effect of silencing domestic dissent and it comes at a time when in Western policy-making circles the utility of Saudi Arabia and MbS is taking clear precedence over the issue of human rights. This is only likely to continue as global energy prices complicate the fortunes of Western governments with the cost of living inexorably increasing.

Economically, the surge in oil price has provided a  welcome relief for Saudi officials. As well, the kingdom has been able to maintain unity with the OPEC+ bloc to ensure that no concessions are made that might adversely affect the price. Moreover, more companies are beginning to present tenders for NEOM with reports of construction already under way on projects such as ‘The Line’.

It is important to stress however, that much of MbS’s improving fortunes have not necessarily been brought about because of his policies, but rather thanks to a reversal of fortunes for his antagonists (notably Biden). Nevertheless, it is becoming increasingly apparent that the crown prince is certainly not the ‘pariah’ Biden promised to make him, and that with the passing of time, there is a clear trajectory towards a normalisation that seemed quite distant only last year.


Members can leave comments about this newsletter on the Today's Newsletter page of the Arab Digest website
follow us on TwitterLinkedIn and Facebook

Copyright © 2022 Arab Digest, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email as you are subscribed to the Arab Digest.
Our mailing address is:
Arab Digest
3rd Floor
207 Regent Street
London, W1B 3HH
United Kingdom



 To unsubscribe from this list email editor@arabdigest.org


This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.